Showing posts with label book reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book reviews. Show all posts

Thursday, January 27, 2011

Medicine as Art: A Few Thoughts on Cutting for Stone by Abraham Verghase

No spoiler information is contained in this post.

A good book. A page turner. I love when I get my hands on one. But I must admit, I am the type of person who can put a good book down. It is always with guilt and regret, but I get distracted by other books, spend too much blogging instead of reading, or just fiddle around with my kids. Sometimes it can take me months to read books that are compelling and I never make it through books that do not grab me.

So, I must admit that I was a little surprised when I read the 658 page novel Cutting for Stone by Abraham Verghese in three days. To say this spellbinding, captivating novel is a page tuner is a crude understatement. Cutting for Stone is a gripping epic that sweeps through six decades and three continents, making the reader part of the powerful and heartrending journey.

Verghese’s debut work of literary fiction is so far-reaching in scope and depth that it cannot be pigeonholed into one genre. There is a touch a mystery, much romance, tons of action, many thrills, a tremendous amount of humor, a plethora of heartbreak, a multitude of surgical drama and most importantly, luminous storytelling.

Despite the high page count and larger-than-life story, the plot of the novel is really quite simple. A beautiful Indian nun who works in a hospital in Ethiopia conceals her pregnancy for nearly nine months, suddenly goes into labor, and gives birth to twins in the middle of night. She dies immediately following the birth which results in the twins’ distraught father (a brilliant British surgeon who was unaware of the pregnancy) to flee the country minutes after the birth. Left behind are twin boys, Marion and Shiva who both eventually embark on careers in medicine after being raised by two kindhearted, loving, compassionate doctors and their zany support staff --a bunch of madcap, doting characters similar to those found in a Dickens novel.

Unlike a Dickens novel, Verghese writes fully developed character histories that are meticulously recounted by Marion, the biological son of surgeon Thomas Stone and Sister Mary Joseph Praise and the adopted son of Hema and Gosh. With meticulous detail, Marion reveals what he knows about the mystery surrounding the twins' conception, their birth, their mother’s death and the disappearance of their father, which propels the action of the novel that unfolds into a saga about family, coming of age, betrayal, love, loss, social unrest, medicine, forgiveness and redemption.

If Stone’s abandonment and betrayal is the stimulus of the first portion of the novel, Shiva’s betrayal of Marion and all the events that spiral out of control after the betrayal drives the latter part of the novel. Secrets, lies, impulsiveness, insensitivity, and selfishness run as rampant in this novel as does kindness, compassion, healing, tenderness, passion and love. Just about every human emotion is rendered eloquently and believably. Verghase is a master at capturing the human spirit without relying on clichés and sappiness. He successfully manages to balance good and evil; life and death; mysticism and realism; and medical care and human acts of comfort.

Balance is a trick that Verghase seems to know well since by profession he is both a doctor and a writer (published two memoirs prior to his work of fiction). It is through his fiction writing that he is able to offer profound observations about and scathing accusations towards the field of medicine. Throughout the novel, he takes a strong line that doctors need to see patients as humans with one doctor asking: “What treatment in an emergency is administered by ear?” After a long silence in a room filled with medical practitioners, another doctor responds, “Words of comfort.”

Comfort -- this is precisely what Verghase offers his readers although he gives a lot of discomfort, upheaval, distress and agony too. But no matter if he is providing details on a bowel removal, discussing the foul smell associated with young women with fistula or explaining the motivation of Eritrean guerrilla fighters, Verghase wastes no words, finds beauty in grotesqueness and makes art out of science.

Verghase is a truly masterful novelist who pulls his readers into a lush and thrilling world where emotions and empiricism commingle beautifully to make a whirlwind saga that holds the reader captive until the end. Cutting for Stone is truly a marvel of a novel.

Monday, January 3, 2011

Obsequiousness is Not Objectivity: A Few Thoughts on Sarah Thornton’s Seven Days in the Art World

The beauty of being a librarian is that sometimes I stumble across a book that I did not know that I wanted to read, which was the case when re-shelving a display led me to Seven Days in the Art World by Sarah Thornton. I was immediately captured by the brief synopsis on the back of the book, “A fly-on-the-wall account of the smart and strange subcultures that make, trade, curate, collect, and hype contemporary art.” The publisher promises the book to be a heavily researched account that pieces together hours of observation and more than 250 insider interviews, and Thornton claims, in her introduction, that as a researcher she is like a “cat on the prowl…curious and interactive but not threatening. Occasionally intrusive, but easily ignored.”

Much like a cat that preens and prunes meticulously, Thornton neatly organizes her ethnography into seven chapters that represents seven different days and seven different aspects of the contemporary art world: an auction (at Christie’s New York), an art school “crit” (at the California Institute of the Arts in Valencia), an art fair (Art Basel), an artist’s studio (belonging to Japanese artist Takashi Murakami), a prize (Britain’s prestigious Turner Prize), a magazine (Artforum) and a biennale (Venice).

Although she intends for the seven chapters to delve deep into the contemporary art world, she provides a surface account of a bizarre world filled with a plethora of air-kissing, trite gossip, a strong sense of self-importance and way too much disposable income that is used to sway the art markets with little regard for aesthetics. Throughout her investigative journey, Thornton follows two different but intersecting paths – money and art. By alternating chapters between the power-players with inflamed egos who buy the art and the progressive artists with inflamed egos who make art, Thornton attempts to show the dynamics and tension between art making, art speculation and art purchasing. But what she gives us is an uneven portrait of the art world with little insight into why someone buys art, what makes one type of art favored over another type, why some startling, innovative contemporary artists are effectively ignored by critics and collectors, and what happens to art works once they are devoured by the status seeking nouveau-riche.

Perhaps Thornton begins her investigation seeking these answers but somewhere in her journey, Thornton loses her resolve, her journalistic verve, her investigative determination, her point-of view and merely becomes a puppet for powerful collectors, curators, critics, dealers, and auctioneers. The chapters on the Christie’s auction, the Art Basel Fair and the Venice Biennale read like a diary of a high school trumpet player who has a crush on the star quarterback and just got befriended by manipulative cheerleaders who have ulterior motives. Thornton becomes so consumed in the universe of money that she fills these chapters with pompous (albeit unwittingly funny) quotes and miniscule, tedious details, making her appear as a gossipy braggart instead of a reporter. Blinded by a whirlwind of glamour and glitz, she feels compelled to share the minutia with her readers with paragraphs such as:

“Back at Cipriani, a British collecting couple are having a dip. He floats; she performs a regal head-up breaststroke. She tells me, in the nicest way, that she finds it irritating when “sporty” Americans insist on pounding up and down the pool. I tell her I am Canadian and she quickly commends this year’s Canadian pavilion as “the best since 2001.” This is Thornton’s general theme: Rich people buy art and too much of this book is devoted to buyers who do not know anything about what they are buying or even why they are buying it. Thornton remains unperturbed by all the gold-lined ignorance and fails to undercover the hypocrisy and artifice of it all. It was no surprise that in her acknowledgements, she admits to allowing certain interviewees to read and make corrections to her drafts; she can’t be an informant if she is going nark on herself. But clearly, she does not want her love affair with the art world to end badly.

In fact, the only art world players who do not seduce her are the artists. Either she does not find artists as sexy as art buyers or she remembers that she is a reporter in their presence. In the chapters about the art school “crit” at the California Institute of the Arts in Valencia, Japanese artist Takashi Murakami’s art studio and Britain’s prestigious Turner Prize, Thornton keeps her distance and allows their dramas to unfold naturally. She fastidiously records a smug MFA student saying “Creative is definitely a dirty word….It’s almost as embarrassing as beautiful, sublime, or masterpiece.” And reveals pop-art superstar Murakami ruminating about his idol Warhol, “I am jealous of Warhol. I’m always asking my production team, ‘Warhol was able to create such an easy painting life, why [is]our work so complicated?’ But, the history knows! My weak point is my oriental background.” Thornton does not shy away from revealing artists’ flaws, foibles and eccentricities.

Artistic eccentricities and idiosyncrasies run rampant in Thornton’s chapter on the Turner Prize 2006, which would have made an outstanding standalone essay in an art periodical with its suspense, humor, tension, and rawness. As she introduces the four nominees to her audience, she reveals two artists to be down-to earth and accessible (Phil Collins, a video artist and Mark Titchner who works in different mediums) and portrays the two female artists, sculptor Rebecca Warren and painter Tomma Abts, as media-phobic, self-absorbed prima donnas. Thornton’s interactions with the artists intermixed with the antics of Nick Serota, director of the Tate; the appearance of Yoko Ono as the prize presenter; and, the tempers and temperaments of the jury makes for an entertaining tale. Sadly, the strength of this chapter is not echoed anywhere else in Thornton’s work.

If the chapter on the Turner prize is the Thornton’s strongest than the chapter that examines Artforum is undeniably the weakest. I must confess after being bored by all the rich people bidding on art at Christie’s in Chapter One, I jumped forward to Chapter Five, The Magazine. Admittedly, the chapter on Artforum contributed greatly to me checking out this book. As a person who loves art and also writes, I probably have fantasized a time or two about being published in Artforum, which Thornton describes as “a trade magazine with crossover cachet and an institution with controversial clout.” She argues that “Artforum is to art what Vogue is to fashion and Rolling Stone was to rock and roll.” Her one-line assessment holds the truth, but she fails to reaffirm the sentiment in the rest of the chapter.

Thornton’s investigation of Artforum is her opportunity to reveal the big reveal; spill the big secrets that give insight into the currents and waves that move and shape the art world. She does not do more than obsess over the writers’ clothes , “Dressed like a dandy in a jacket, vest and tie of remarkably well coordinated plaids… “ and “Dressed entirely in black, with a hairless head and solemn manner “ and “Bright-eyed, compact, clad in a vermillion suit” as well as what the staffers eat “…Thai noodles out cardboard take boxes .“ This chapter is made up of polemical tidbits, guarded explanations and rehashed common knowledge. Her time at Artforum reveals nothing revolutionary or even newsworthy other than she had to trade writing for Artforum’s online magazine in return for having access to their offices. Once again Thornton tosses out her objectivity for acceptance from the insiders.

Thornton’s conversion from outsider to insider in her Seven Days in the Art World, made me remember my two days in art world and my conversion from an outsider who desperately wanted to be an insider to an outsider who discovered insiders are bunch of elitists with expensive shoes and no taste. As a commission-only sales assistant at a small-time art gallery in downtown Denver, located beside an adult novelty shop and across the street from two x-rated theatres, I was forced to push overpriced subpar artwork to people looking for the perfect accessory to match their couch. In theory, the idea of working in a room covered in art is as great working in a building filled with books. But unlike the library where my help is appreciated and my education is respected, patrons of the art gallery felt compelled to flash their money and seemed more annoyed than appreciative of any art knowledge that I attempted to share. Knowing how much insurance to buy for their art work was far more important than knowing about the influences present in the work. I did not have the stomach to mix my love of art with other’s people’s money, so I quickly bailed without a two-week notice and started working in more artful, kinder, gentler profession—bill collecting. Having someone call me “a skank” for asking them to make a payment on their past due Discover credit card bill was far less demoralizing than being asked to call an artist to see if he could re-do a painting in hues of pink and burgundy that would be better suited for the client's bedroom.

Although my foray in the art world was brief and disconcerting, my love of art remained unscathed. So it is with sadness and disappointment , I return Seven Days in the Art World to the shelf. But, I still hope that one day I will walk out of the library with the book that truly tells me how and why the art world spins.

Monday, December 6, 2010

A Provocative Tale of Captivity: A Few Thoughts on Emma Donoghue’s Room

Five-year-olds are cute, funny, charming and adorable when they are biologically related to you. When you are not legally obligated to think they are enchanting, five-year-olds are just plain annoying, a little obnoxious and perhaps the biggest attention seekers in the world. There is probably no five-year-old more annoying than Jack. He is incessantly talking about Dora and Sponge Bob and still breastfeeds. Now the fact that Jack is the biological son of a twenty-six-year-old and her captor (who abducted her when she nineteen) makes Jack’s story worthy of the reader's time.

It is through the eyes of Jack that Emma Donoghue tells the story of Room, a compassionate suspense thriller that has touches of crime fiction balanced with infinite parent-child love. Although Donoghue takes an enormous risk by using a kindergarten-age child with no formal schooling as the narrator, readers are able to get past the gimmicky quality of the narrative voice to appreciate Jack’s insights that make this novel radically different from other exploitative captivity tales. Based on headlines about young girls in captivity like Elizabeth Fritzl, Natascha Kampusch, Sabine Dardenne, Jaycee Lee Dugard and Elizabeth Smart, the author manages to surpass media hype and create a profoundly original tale of a young mother giving her son a healthy well-balanced life in a 12-foot-square room. They play games, read books, have physical education classes, talk about God and Heaven, and watch a substantial amount of TV for both information and escape. Jack feels his truncated world around him deeply, has an unlimited imagination and makes everything a character by referring to all objects as proper names Room, Rug, Sink, Wardrobe, Plant and Tooth (which literally is his mother’s decayed tooth that she extracts herself and he saves as an unusual companion). Everything in the room is tranquil and everything outside the room is horrifying and foreign.

But when his mom, who is only referred to as Ma throughout the book, learns that her captor Old Nick lost his job, she fears what he would do to them before he ever allowed the bank to discover his soundproof shed. So, she plans an escape that fully rests on Jack’s shoulder. She insists that he must be brave and he insists that he is scared, so together they create the “word sandwich” that they call “scave.” Although he is “scave,” Jack follows his charge and the action becomes spellbinding. The events after the escape attempt are poignant and darkly stirring. At times the post-escape reality depicted is far more treacherous and repugnant than their life in confinement; sometimes so atrocious that is uncomfortable to read. But despite the shocking twists and turns, readers stay connected to Donohue’s unflinching tale of horror, rebirth and genuine parental love. The freshness of this novel will be attracting readers for a longtime to come.

Friday, December 3, 2010

Missed Potential: A Few Thoughts on Kim Edwards' The Memory Keeper’s Daughter

I love literary tragedy. Works of literature that depict horrific, catastrophic events or deep devastating psychological portraits of personal destruction. And of course, only unhappy endings truly satisfy me. But the story told most be truly tragic and not just sad. There is a huge difference between tragic and just plain depressing.

Kim Edwards’ The Memory Keeper’s Daughter fits the description of depressing not tragic; an exceedingly sad book in a non-particularly interesting way that does not match its fascinating premise. It is the Winter of 1964 in a middle of a snow storm; an orthopedic surgeon’s wife goes into labor. The obstetrician fails to arrive for the birth; the doctor delivers his own child, a healthy boy. Moments later, he is greeted with the surprise of a second child, a daughter with Down Syndrome. In a rash decision, he gives the impaired baby to his nurse to delivery to a home for mentally retarded children; he then tells his wife that their second child died. Unable to leave the child, the unmarried nurse, who secretly loves the doctor, keeps the baby, moves away and starts her life anew. Now that is a plot with tension and much potential for many exciting plot twists.

The potential remains unfulfilled. Edwards misses all opportunities to create a tension filled book that interweaves the lives of the two babies separated at birth. Instead she fills her novel with a bunch of despicable people who keep secrets, behave badly and evoke little empathy. Dr. David Henry, whose childhood was burdened by his parents’ constant concern and worry for his sickly sister, abandons his daughter supposedly to spare his wife and healthy child the rigors and heartbreak associated with raising a mentally retarded child. His wife, Norah Henry, devastated by the supposed loss of her child becomes an adulterous drunk. Trapped in the mayhem of his parents’ failed marriage, Paul Henry becomes an angry rebellious teenager who is indifferent to his father and behaves poorly. The longsuffering nurse, Caroline Gill is a bit of a heroine figure by saving the unwanted baby, but is she really a hero? She kept a baby from her natural mother. Then, there is title character and impaired child, Phoebe who could have been piece that held this book cohesively together, but she nothing more than a literary device who only appears in a handful of touching, tear-inducing scenes.

The Memory Keeper’s Daughter drags along with all the characters keeping their secrets with little tension that the secrets will be revealed, which makes for a long and boring read. By the time that the big reveal occurs, readers are so beaten down by all the redundancy, introduction of strange, irrelevant characters and uninteresting plot developments that the climax provokes very little emotion. Sadly, the premise of this book is substantially better than the actual book. This is a book that can be skipped and not missed in anyway.

Saturday, November 6, 2010

Adorable Canine Redeems Lame, Cheesy Novel: A Few Thoughts on The Art of Racing in the Rain

Shocked! This was the look on the faces of my fellow book club members when I gave Garth Stein’s “The Art of Racing in the Rain” a thumb in the middle during our traditional opening Thumb up/Thumb down ceremony. It was strongly anticipated that I would not like this book because I am petrified of dogs; I ridicule gimmicky narratives; I do not typically read New York Times Best Sellers; and, most importantly, I despise uplifting endings.

For all the above reasons, I really should have loathed this book, but I did not on two simple grounds: Enzio, the charming narrating dog suckered me in with his jokes and wisdom and the racing metaphors absolutely captured my imagination. In actuality, The Art of Racing in the Rain is a simplistic story of a man, a woman, their child, the man’s dog and the woman’s horrible parents. Not much interesting happens. Man gets dog; man marries woman; dog and woman don’t care for each other too much; woman gets cancer; and the grandparents try to steal the child from her father. In terms of plot, this novel is really sort of puerile until the dog comes along and gives the reader an “under the table” view.

Enzio narrates every detail with a four-legged perspective. We hear from his point of view the details of human mating rituals; we learn what is like for a dog to discover a rancid chicken nugget under a kitchen table; we experience firsthand a dog’s thirst for squirrel’s blood and how that is a magnificent metaphor for irrational acts of human passion. And of course, Enzio charismatically draws us in with his T.V. addiction, hatred of monkeys and ardent belief that he would transform into a human upon his death. Reviewing that list, it still surprises me that this ridiculous book appealed to me, but the success of this book lies in the humanistic portrayal of the universe from a non-human point of view. Furthermore, it gave me that tingling in the nose about to cry feeling many times.

In fact, for a moment or two, I adored Enzio so much that I wished I liked real life dogs (not likely to ever happen). Enzio is a literary device not a dog, a literary device that makes this non-dog-lover’s experience with this novel very different than a dog lover’s encounter. Generally, dog-lover’s were ecstatic about this book. For the non-dog lover, Stein’s book is a light, tolerable read. If you have a few hours to kill, this one will make you laugh and tear up a little.

Thursday, September 30, 2010

The Fictional Housewives of the Hunan Province: A Few Thoughts on Lisa See’s Snow Flower and the Secret Fan

“Snow Flower and the Secret Fan is written with a stately but unremarkable prettiness; it is not a book that will make its mark for reasons of style. But Ms. See has worked enough joy, pain and dramatic weepiness …to give it a quiet staying power. It's liable to be read by women's groups and valued for its quaintness… But what will work best for this book is its own secret message: cultures vary, but old sames and same-olds don't change,” wrote Janet Maslin in the New York Times on August 15, 2005.

Maslin’s scathing review of Lisa See’s fourth novel shocks me because her argument that See’s book is melodramatic, quaint and typical cannot be reinforced with textual evidence. Throughout her review she calls this novel a soap opera and argues that the two main characters Snow Flower and Lily have “sudsy lives” that develop into the “rainstorms of bitchery” commonly associated “with this novel's underlying genre.” Although she wants to label this novel to be a soap opera/melodrama, Snowflower and the Secret Fan belongs to genre of historical fiction specifically and women’s literature more generally. See’s novel provides a fictional but reasonably accurate account of life in Nineteenth Century Chinese life derived from months of research. And even more importantly, the novel chronicles and examines the relationship of two women from early adolescence until death separates them in adulthood.

The two women in question are Snow Flower and Lily who are a laotong pair also called old sames (meaning they were born on the same day in the same year, hold the same place in their birth order, have the same number of living and dead siblings and started their foot-binding at the same age on the same day). A laotong match, which should last a lifetime, is a more intimate and committed relationship than an arranged marriage that allows husbands to have concubines. As Lily’s aunt explains, "A laotong relationship is made by choice for the purpose of emotional companionship and eternal fidelity. A marriage is not made by choice and has only one purpose – to have sons."

Emotional companionship is exactly what Snow Flower and Lily give each through tumultuous changes in their lives. Lily climbs up the social ladder as a result of to her beautiful and tiny “golden lily” feet while Snow Flower slides down tragically into destitution due to her father’s addiction to opium and whores. As their social spheres shift, communication becomes increasingly complicated. But thanks to nu shu (a secret women’s only language that they embroidered on the secret fan) and clandestine meetings in remote villages, their relationship continues, despite the disapproval of Lily’s new family, until a misunderstanding about their “eternal fidelity” triggers a regretful and tragic dispute that unravels their bond.

Snow Flower and Lily’s bond, which was allowed only after both girls completed the torturous process of foot binding, is in some way compensation for the agony that must be endured to become a woman and a wife. The comfort that they find in each other’s arms reinforces their value as females, giving them validation in a culture were girls are oppressed and underappreciated. Their passion for each other glides, over the years, into the areas of tenderness, love, eroticism, jealousy, fury, cruelty, retribution , isolation, regret, reconciliation, grief and repentance. Each emotion moves the narrative forward.

Yes, the action is fast-moving; drama is high in the inner-sanctum of the women’s sitting room; emotions are unbridled, but See does not teeter on the border of melodrama. Instead, she creates a fascinating portrayal of femininity in relation to social status and expected gender roles. The author details all kinds all female relationships: mother/daughter, mother-in-law/daughter-in-law/, aunt/niece, mistress/servant, matchmaker/client, cousins, biological sisters, sworn sisters and laotongs. Each relationship is multifaceted with its own unique rules. Although these relationships seem locked away in distant history, the complexities and intricacies of these female relationships are very much alive today in daily life and in women’s literature.

From start to finish, Snow Flower and the Secret Fan is a stunning novel that informs with historical facts, enlightens with intensely affecting prose, entertains with suspense and triumph and gracefully astonishes readers with grotesqueness, eroticism and brutality. Joy, sorrow, love, hate, jealously, compassion, life, death…it all exists in Lisa See’s wonderfully haunting and mesmerizing tale of female friendship. This novel is not just an example of great women’s literature it is a flawless novel within the canon of World Literature.

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

Little Bee Fails to Sting: A Few Thoughts on Chris Cleave’s Latest Novel

This post contains a small amount of spoiler information.

A few weeks ago, I posed the question: Is it possible to read too many depressing British novels? Of course, the answer is “no.” However, I have definitely reached my threshold on British literary rubbish disguised as literary fiction and riveting fodder for book club groups. Chris Cleave’s Little Bee fits in the category of good intentions dressed up as literature and is just one more book that can be added to my list of “not good books” that I completed for book club despite my desire to ditch the book in favor of something more likeable and moving. (No offense, selector. You did a great job selecting a book of the perfect length with hot topics that will lead to an interesting discussion. You know I would be complaining even if we would have read Lolita like we originally planned. Blame the author not the selector.)

It should have occurred to me that there was something stinky in Nigeria when this book was being promoted with this caveat: “The publishers of Chris Cleave's new novel 'don't want to spoil' the story by revealing too much about it, and there's good reason not to tell too much about the plot's pivot point. All you should know going in to Little Bee is that what happens on the beach is brutal, and that it braids the fates of a 16-year-old Nigerian orphan (who calls herself Little Bee) and a well-off British couple--journalists trying to repair their strained marriage with a free holiday--who should have stayed behind their resort's walls…”

When the publisher does not want to give a summary that means there just isn’t much substance there to preview. Actually, there are a lot of ridiculous confrontations and melodrama that occurs throughout the novel but nothing that amounts to a logical plot. During the first three chapters, it appears that Cleave creates a thought-provoking, intriguing novel about the treatment of refugees at immigration detention holding centers. He builds up tremendous suspense about the much touted scene on the beach that brings Little Bee into the lives of Sarah and Andrew, a British couple who have a precocious four-year-old Charlie as well as a troubled marriage due to her affair with Lawrence, a weaselly government employee who is married with children.

After the beach scene (which is not as monstrous and barbaric as the publisher’s blurb intimates) occurs, the book falls apart. Yes, the violence is brutal but it seems to be too unbelievable that mercenaries would perform slow torture and sadistic bargaining opposed to just killing everyone on the beach. Furthermore, why would anyone go to Nigeria to repair their marriage? Andrew and Sarah are both journalists, so they could have been there for work. But, Cleave chooses to have the struggling couple go to a dangerous beach for a second honeymoon—just ludicrous. Since the remainder of the novel hinges on the absurdity of the beach scene, Cleave’s strong start to his novel unravels as he strings one confrontation or melodramatic moment after another to keep the book moving. Even in flashbacks that reveal Sarah and Andrew’s life together, Cleave creates histrionics that just are unbelievable. For instance, the scene where Lawrence introduces his mistress to her husband is hauntingly awkward and darkly comic, but in reality neither the wife nor the husband would have allowed Lawrence to complete his introduction.

But, their meeting is nowhere near as incongruous as the calculating and manipulative banter between Lawrence and Little Bee. Following Andrew’s suicide, Lawrence quickly usurps the dead man’s side of the bed and becomes a possessive fixture in Sarah’s life, which not only makes Little Bee uneasy but makes her equally possessive and aggressive. Little Bee’s response to Lawrence’s threats seems incompatible with her saccharine naiveté. Would a sweet sixteen-year-old Nigerian who seems so ignorant of both British and adult ways really threaten and blackmail a male government employee? Perhaps Cleave is trying to make Little Bee multidimensional, but instead of roundness he creates illogical bipolarity. She deviates from strong to weak with no shades of ordinary in between.

Although Cleave never allows Little Bee to materialize into a believable character, he succeeds in making Sarah the perfect cheating bitch and irresponsible mother who has moments of selflessness, compassion and benevolence. She is neither fully could good or fully bad and possesses a believable amount of ambivalence. Although readers may not like her, her complexity helps redeem the novel. Sadly, she would be a more interesting character if the two men she vacillated between were more distinctive. Andrew and Lawrence are pretty much same man. They both are cowards with very little self-confidence or raison d'être. With his rendering of both men, it is like Cleave looked to American sitcoms writers who only know how to write men as buffoons and subordinates to their smart wives. It is like American comedic writers have forgotten how to write strong men and this is also the case with Cleave. There is nothing manly or attractive about Lawrence and Andrew’s only redeemable quality might be the documentation about Nigeria that he compiled.

The incongruities in Little Bee’s character and the pale sketching of Lawrence and Arthur makes the characterization in this book very flawed. But at the same time, the characterization is probably the best part of this book in comparison to dialogue and plot, which are shoddily put together. The ending of the book is as ridiculous as all the other melodramatic moments in this book. It is a shame that the plot components are not more evolved because it appears that Cleave is trying extraordinarily hard to write an important book about brutality in Africa and the conditions that refugees face when entering England. His research fills his novel; his passion for the topic resonates; his dark wit shines at moments in this novel; and, his awareness of a writerly style necessary to propel a book from competent storytelling to high art is evident. Sometimes his comic moments are just too forced. For instance, the ridiculously long list of suicide methods that Little Bee would employ if the men came to get her is insanely overwrought. Cleave also overloads his book with metaphors. After I read the lovely extended use of the British pound as metaphor, he quickly follows up with nail polish and scars as metaphors – just too much in a small literary space. Metaphors need time and space. No need to show his entire literary prowess in the first 30 pages. But, I really do admire Cleave’s effort with this book. Little Bee would be really great with a different plot, fully developed characters, more realistic dialogue, less metaphors and an alternative ending.

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Are you sure I read the right book? Review of The Help by Kathyrn Stockett

"You won't be able to put this book down." I heard this statement from many friends and patrons when they were recommending Kathryn Stockett's The Help. Their accolades set my expectations high and created great anticipation. It did not take long for my expectations to plummet, the anticipation to dissipate, and for me to put the book down.

Set in the early years of the Civil Rights Movement, this novel explores the complex relationships between black domestics and their white employers. The story unfolds through the voices of Aibileen, a sweet silent maid who loves caring for white babies until they grow-up to be just like their parents; Minny, a sassy, hefty black maid with a drunken, abusive husband; and, Skeeter, a white, upper-class recent graduate of Ole Miss who wants to change the world with her writing.

It is the stereotypical rendering of the three stock characters as well as inaccurate dialects, a multitude of historical errors and meandering subplots that give this book a false sense of gravitas. Despite its good authorial intentions, The Help is just a well-meaning, pseudo-political fluff piece that is a quick, easy read and a perfect candidate to be a best seller. It is a book with socio-political commentary that doesn’t require too much investment or effort on the reader’s part. Reading this book is like throwing money in collection plate during mass; you know it supports a good cause but you are just relieved it doesn’t require too much work on your part.

From the start, Stockett sucked me into this book with her sympathetic portrayal of Aibileen, a black maid who has raised 17 white children and is mostly seen taking care of the feisty Mae Mobley. Stockett goes out of her way to draw strong dichotomies between Aibileen, the sweet nurturing nanny who is protective of the baby and Mae Mobley’s white mother whose emotions towards her daughter range from indifferent to neglectful to hostile. Stockett sends her message: Black nannies raise white babies better than their white mamas. She repeats this idea consistently throughout the book by having just about every white character fondly recall their black nanny. But when it comes down it, Aibileen is just the stereotypical good, loyal maid who blindly obeys white authority.

Similarly, Minny is the stereotypical “Mammy” in every way from her short, rotund figure to her sassy mouth to her amazing cooking skills. It seems like Stockett watched Gone with the Wind a bunch times as inspiration to create Minny. The smart-mouth maid only becomes a redeemable character when her storyline is linked to Miss Celia, the poor white girl who like the black maids is discriminated against by the southern high society ladies. But although there are some tear-jerking scenes between Celia and Minny, there is not enough substance to elevate these characters beyond the caricatures of the white trash matron and the Mammy.

Then, there is the third and most despicable main character, Skeeter. Technically, she is the heroine of book; the white woman who is going to help the condition of black domestics by writing about their lives and their relationships with their white employers. I am trying to not be offended that more than one person has told me Skeeter reminds them of me. I guess at twenty-three I too would have put lives at risk to get a book deal and a great job at a magazine in New York. Skeeter is completely selfish and reckless with the lives of her sources, who could have been severely punished under the Jim Crow laws for speaking out negatively against their white employers. Skeeter’s only intention with writing the book is to get the job that she wanted. She exploited and used black women to achieve her goals, which completely undermines the point of her book. The same implication can also be applied to Stockett and The Help. She takes on a somewhat noble pursuit but mostly just creates a watercooler topic that would appeal to book clubs. Sadly, she achieved her goal with this book. The marketing for this book is geared towards book clubs and general readers that propel books to the New York Times Best Seller List.

This book has all trappings of a book club sensation/Walmart end-cap. I am so done being trapped and tricked by lure of good reviews by general readers. I am officially done with the New York Times Best Sellers unless the books have also won the National Book Award, the Pulitzer, or the Mann Booker Prize. Life is too short for substandard popular books. I would have been better off spending my time reading To Kill a Mocking Bird. (No offense to my friends who like this book, but I found this work to be absolutely unpalatable.) It is weak on substance and downright pejorative. A close reading of this book reveals it to be highly racist and formulaic. All the black women talk in a Southern dialect and the white southern women all speak like the Queen of England. Any awareness that Stockett was trying to create is completely eroded by her caricatures, inconsistent language usage, improbable plot twists and racist stereotyping. The Help does not measure up to the hype in any way. Don’t waste your time or money.

Thursday, July 29, 2010

First Comes Marriage then Comes the Devastation: Review of Ian McEwan’s On Chesil Beach

Ian McEwan’s astonishingly heartbreaking book, On Chesil Beach opens with the line: "They were young, educated, and both virgins on this, their wedding night, and they lived in a time when conversation about sexual difficulties was plainly impossible." McEwan’s opener is a good indication that this novel is about young love, sex, unspoken expectations and paralyzing repression that simply isn’t going to end well for the couple. The suspense of the work is built around the questions of what has caused their great miscommunication; how badly will their honeymoon go and what consequences will be suffered due to an awkward wedding night?

The two innocents in question are Edward Mayhew and Florence Ponting. He is a historian who is the son of a principled schoolmaster and a sweet, brain-damaged mother. She is a virtuoso violinist who is the daughter of a workaholic corporate tycoon and a workaholic mother who is an Oxford philosopher, preferring Schopenhauer over her own daughters. After a yearlong tender (but not particularly intimate) courtship, the couple exchange marital vows, receive lovely well-wishes from friends and family, and finally are alone in the honeymoon suite on their wedding night.

"What stood in their way?" asks the narrator, "Their personalities and pasts, their ignorance and fear, timidity, squeamishness, lack of entitlement or experience, then the tail end of a religious prohibition, their Englishness and class, and history itself."

Alone in that room with the four-post bed taunting them, the couple possess innocence, hope and promise. But, it does not take long for their naïveté to be jaded through a series of miscues, fumbling and ham-fisted caresses. She approaches the marital bed with a sense of “visceral dread” and he follows her with feelings of excitement, nervousness and inadequacy. None of their uncertainties are articulated verbally, and they grossly misinterpret each other’s non-verbal cues. She is so fearful that her legs twitch and he misreads it for excitement. This series of miscommunication creates a bizarre tragicomedy that focuses on the intimate details of their consummation but in no way enters the realm of slapstick or eroticism. The comedic elements of the sexual awkwardness become devastatingly tragic in a very short period time.

The sexual encounter occurs in real time and the life-alerting events unfold in probably less than two-hours. In order to break-up the drama in the bedroom while also heightening the suspense, McEwan’s interweaves the stories of both of their upbringings and the mythology that they created about their accidental meeting and subsequent betrothal. Their class, their parental relationships, their educations, their passions, their values, their anxieties and their differing music tastes all climb into bed with them and dance towards reconciliation, but the beat is never found and the perpetual stumbling knocks them both down permanently and irreparably. The beauty is in watching their synchronicity tragically dissipate into experienced ruins.

The magic of this book is how much richness fills 160 pages. The brevity of this book makes it more of a novella than a novel technically, but it is a complete novel in every way. McEwan, who has a reputation for creating cold characters in his forensic style of prose, in this work crafts beautifully rounded characters with lushness and precision. Both Edward and Florence are likable and believable. Their warmth is felt through the page and pulls the reader into their calamity. While creating such full portraits of his main characters, he also touches upon the issues of class, politics, familial influences, repression, miscommunication, and social expectations in 1962 prior to the sexual revolution.

With the pure grace and poise exhibited in this novel, it is no surprise that it was short-listed for the Man Booker Prize in 2007. This work of literary fiction epitomizes what great fiction is -- interesting characters, original plot, intriguing setting, emotional dialogue, and a satisfying ending even if it is not a happy ending. Yes, this book is tragic and depressing. A month later, I still get a little sad when I think about Edward and Florence. But can one ever get enough tragically heartbreaking English dramas? Of course not.

Wednesday, July 28, 2010

A Few Notes and Arbitrary Thoughts about The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo

Publishers must think that readers in America and Great Britain are either prudish or simple or both. Someone in the publishing world decided that readers would not buy an English translation of a book with the title Men Who Hate Women, which is the original name for the first novel in Stieg Larsson’s crime thriller trilogy. Marketers probably believed that The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo was sexier, more appealing and perhaps a more mysterious title that would pique readers’ interests. Perhaps a sexy title would distract from all the problems in this strange mess of a book (that oddly entices, repulses, intrigues, and bores me in an alternating sequence.) This book has so many problems that it is best to get them out of the way immediately:

1. Granted the title is catchy and provocative, but it is hugely misleading. Although the rail-thin, emotionally damaged girl with the dragon tattoo, properly known as Lisbeth Salander, is a crucial part of the novel, she is by no means the main protagonist and plays only a moderate role in the novel’s plot, suspense, and action. This book is truly about men who hate women. Salander, who at one point is described as the perfect victim, is an example of a female that has been hated by men specifically and exploited under a patriarchal order her whole life. But, she is just one of the many characters in this book.

2. This 590 page book is about 300 pages of unedited, unnecessary rubbish that meanders and takes up space. The intended financial intrigue is anything but intriguing and could be completely cut from the book, particularly in the last few chapters following such a thrilling climax. Plus, the entire detailed family lineage is cumbersome.
3. Alone Salander and Michael Blomviskt are emotionally dysfunction flat characters. The story drags through their introductions and personal travails. Together, they ignite the novel and make pages practically turn themselves. It should not have taken 300 pages for the characters to meet.

4. With the exception Henrik Vanger, there are no positive portrayals of men (even Blomvist is severely flawed). And, the villains are just pure evil. The best villains in literature are complex with a streak of good that is dominated by their more sinister ways.

5. The plot and subplots reach a ridiculous level of absurdity and improbability, but yet the ride into ludicrousness is quite exhilarating.

6. The references to technology will eventually make the book feel dated before its time.

7. The relationship between Erica Berger and Blomviskt is unbelievable and poorly sketched. It is not likely that any husband would stand for his wife sleeping with another man that regularly for such a sustained period of time. Larsson  gives us an on-paper scenario of the relationship without the complexities of human emotions. Likewise, most of the supporting cast members are either cardboard or tissue paper.

8. Finally, the biggest turn off for me and the main reason why I will not read the remaining two books: Excessive sexual violence with gratuitous details. Larsson’s portrayal of violence against women (and some men) is fascinating and I believe well-intended for advocacy and education, but the book would have been brought to a closer level of literary fiction if the violence would have been toned down, and the brutality would have been discussed in different terms. All those terrible things could have occurred with less gruesome depiction.

Although I am sure there are more things that I could list, why be nitpicky? Once readers get beyond a few stock supporting characters and the boring financial plot, they can devour this wonderful mess of a book that is an absolute page-turner in parts. Without a doubt, this is a mysterious and exhilarating crime thriller that may be more sophisticated than some of its contemporary peers. There are numerous umbrella themes in this novel that kept me hooked. (Book Club Moms, start thinking about these topics that we’ll be discussing tonight.) Here are some the best and most interesting themes, characters and events in this novel:

1. Sexual, physical and emotional abuse against women and children is the most dominant theme in the book. Although Larsson goes to great length to provide gory details, he is not necessarily being exploitative of women and children. With the inclusion of the sexual assault statistics at the beginning of each section, Larsson is educating his readers. He is absolutely writing a parable of sorts (albeit twisted, complex and gratuitous at times). He seems to be taking an approach of advocacy against the violence towards women opposed to portraying it for commercial gain. (There is no doubt that is a debatable assertion.)

2. Although Lisbeth Salander is not the heart of the novel as the title suggests (Or, is she? A point worth discussing), she is a fascinating anti-hero. She is a young woman who is emotionally crippled and has been declared a ward of the state due to incompetency. But at the same time, she is a highly functional dysfunctional person. She is firm on her convictions: a bad life doesn’t give a person an excuse to abuse another person; if you have a problem fix it yourself and do what it takes to get the job done even if it means breaking the law. She is simultaneously simple and complex. But, it could be argued she is far simpler prior to meeting Blomvist. Her character really borders on cliché in the first half of the book. Was any one surprised that an attractive tattooed, leather-wearing girl with multiple piercing and nearly shaved hair was bi-sexual? That is a stock character from the 1990s. She becomes a far more original character when she inexplicably, unwittingly and unwillingly falls in the love with Blomvist. Salander is a new kind of feminist.

3. The romance between Salander and Blomvist buoys this book to a different level. Perhaps crime thriller aficionados did not take much notice of the romance, but it was really the only thing that motivated me to continue reading. I was only moderately interested in Harriet’s disappearance, vaguely interested in the serial killing subplot, didn’t really care about the crazy Vanger clan, was terrified by the violence and was completely bored by the Wennerstrom affair. Salander and Blomvist keep the book moving and their chemistry is complex, sexy, fascinating and passionate. Larsson’s masterfully pairs two damaged, unconventional protagonists to make a perverse super couple that solves crimes and helps to heal each other to some extent. The twists and turns of their relationship were more intriguing and mysterious than the mystery they were solving. The condition of their relationship on the final page of this book made me want to read the second book until I read the prologue of The Girl Who Played with Fire.  All the violence starts up again, so I’ll just have to find a summary of the next two books to see what happens to Salander and Blomvist.

Other important things to consider: the link between Nazism and violence against women and children; the role of parental guidance or lack of it in the lives of these characters; friendship and trust; religious fanaticism, privacy, and journalistic ethics.

Although The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is a highly flawed book, it cannot be dismissed as a genre read. Larsson tackles enough serious issues in this novel for to be considered social commentary. If it wasn’t for book club, I would have never read this book. But, I guess it doesn’t hurt to leave my comfort zone every ten or twelve years. Now back to E.M. Forster’s Howards End.

Wednesday, June 30, 2010

Tastes Like Broccoli: Review of Out Stealing Horses by Per Petterson

I like broccoli. By no means is it my favorite vegetable that honor belongs to brussels sprouts, but I rank it high above green beans. Sometimes I just move the broccoli around on my plate until I am ready to eat it. Sometimes, especially in stir-fry, I just leave it on my plate for no reason other than I would rather eat the carrots and bell peppers. Sometimes I come back to it. Sometimes I don't. Sometimes I need a little cheese or butter to make the broccoli go down a little better. Broccoli is good for me and really is a fine tasting vegetable.

My feelings towards broccoli can also be applied to my experience reading Out Stealing Horses by Per Petterson, a literary work that nourishes me with both a compelling narrative and a nuanced literary style. But, like my desire for broccoli, my enthusiasm levels for this book wane substantially. Sometimes I want to devour and sometimes I want to leave it. Sometimes I prefer something with a different flavor. But, every time I come back it, Petterson's prose sustains and enriches me.

Out Stealing Horses is not a quick beach read or even a practical novel for busy moms who do not have long stretches of time to read. Fortunately, due to the brevity of this detailed-filled and weighty book, not many long uninterrupted sessions are needed, but sporadic readings do not work well with this novel, a slow and quiet work of literary fiction.

Petterson's novel develops as slowly and quietly as the secluded and tranquil environment in Eastern Norway that becomes home for Trond Sander, a 67-year-old city dweller, who no longer has an interest in society after the death of his second wife and his sister. His plans to cure his loneliness and melancholy through solitude, communing with nature and by engaging in hard physical labor. He shows no remorse about not communicating with his two adult daughters from his first marriage and has no interest in making new friends. He is content listening to World BBC on his radio and re-reading Charles Dickens novels, a life-long passion. He functions adequately with his emotional malaise until one night he meets his (many miles away) neighbor and his past comes back to hit him with the same force of the car accident the killed his wife three years prior.

The man who steps out of the shadows is Lars, the brother of his best childhood friend. Their encounter disrupts Trond's tranquility and gives him an emotional jolt of remembrance. Seeing Lars catapults him back to the summer of 1948, when he was fifteen-years-old and participated in the playful game of stealing horses, which is simply borrowing the neighbor's horses for a joyful gallop across the countryside with his favorite childhood companion, Jon. But the glory of the pastoral summer did not last long when Trond and Jon's game of stealing horses ultimately leads to Lars accidentally shooting his twin brother by the name of Odd; this tragedy triggers Trond's coming of age as well as the loss of both his best friend and his father.

Petterson slowly allows the story to unfold through subtle alternating between Trond as an old man, who is tightly-wound, spiritually vacant, and emotionally numb and Trond as a young man, who is coming to terms with his forced manhood and the issues of sexuality, adultery, wage-earning, and war time activities. When chronically listing the events of the story, there are many intense and action filled moments in this novel. But, Petterson prefers to tell the story in way that conceals any excitement or adventure. He conveys the details of a shooting during an act from the Norwegian Resistance Movement after World War II with the same snail pace as he recounts timbers falling in the forest. Nothing moves swiftly in this book, which is part of its charm and its tediousness. (I recommend reading this book in an upright position and armed with caffeine. Read only at bedtime, if you want to fall asleep immediately).

Much like my ambivalent feelings towards the novel's pacing, I have mixed feelings about the protagonist. On one hand, he is a tragic man who evokes sympathy and empathy. He is a victim. As a boy, he is abandoned by his father. He is a man scorned by his first wife and becomes a mourning hermit after his second wife's death. He knows pain and sadness. But, is that pain and sadness a good enough excuse to repeat his father's mistake of disappearing without making his children aware of his location, situation or intentions? Trond as an old man is emotionally impotent. When he had the chance to resolve the mystery of his childhood by asking Lars: "Did you take the place that was rightfully mine? Did you have years out my life that I should have lived?" He didn't do it. When he had the chance to make things right with his daughter, the most he could do was promise her that he would get a telephone. Trond is a man of inaction and leaves his past and present unsettled perhaps purposefully, perhaps intentionally but most likely out of fear. Because of his hesitation and reticence, Trond's story plays out nothing like the Dickens' novels that inspire him. There is no nice and neat Dickensian ending, where all the characters end up where they should be and with the good people who love them. Trond remains alone and unsettled -- very Norwegian and Post-Modern.

Overall, I appreciate this novel for its artistry and restraint in language (this probably should be attributed to the English translation), and its compelling story. But, I did not fall in the love with this novel because I failed to connect to the characters, setting or time period. This novel falls in three major genres: a boys' coming of age tale, a father-son drama, and a personal history (told from an old man's perspective). Truthfully, as sexist as it may be, I tend to not embrace stories with male protagonists; probably the reason why I didn't like Moby Dick or Catcher in the Rye. Perhaps I would have been more likely to latch onto this story if it was told from a feminine perspective. I certainly have an obsession with mother-daughter tales, and Moll Flanders remains my favorite bildungsroman. I love to fall in love with books; it just didn't happen in case. Out Stealing Horses is a nice book with adequate flavor; it is a book that I will not savor for very long or have any desire to re-visit. But like broccoli, it wasn't the best or the worse thing to consume. So if you have nothing else on your plate that interests your palate, give Per Petterson's novel a try.

Author's Note: For our book club thumbs up/thumbs down survey, I give it a firm thumbs in the middle. Ladies, have a productive and entertaining meeting without me. I'll be back for July's meeting to discuss The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo. I am starting the book today and am dreading going so far outside of my comfort zone with crime fiction, but the reviews are good and it has won awards. So, I am not taking that big of a risk. Thank you so much for not torturing me Twilight.

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

A Beautiful and Artful Balancing Act: Review of Let the Great World Spin by Colum McCann

Cocaine and naked bodies -- When I got to this unconventional love scene in the gloriously dizzying novel and National Book Award Winner for Fiction, Let the Great World Spin by Colum McCann, I scribbled in the margins of the book, "Will write something that I erotic before I die." Re-read the scene about two more times. Crossed out my words and wrote, "Will do something that erotic in my lifetime." So, goes my interactive adventure with a novel that made me want to write, cry, laugh, and send the author a box of chocolates, my bra, and a note of my endearing love.

McCann's latest novel has no plot in sight, complex character development, a non-linear timeline, no consistency in voice, tone, or narrative style, and prose that flows like poetry with cleverness and tender tragedy underpinning each sentence. Let the Great World Spin is as flawless, delicate and magical as Philippe Petit, the French acrobat who on August 7, 1974 walked across a tightrope between the World Trade Center Towers. His gravity defying, law-breaking spectacle connects the fibers of about a dozen diverse narratives that unfold in the foreground of a decaying, corrupt, debaucherous New York City, loaded with prostitutes, drugs, and anti-Vietnam sentiment.

On that hot summer day, spectators were mesmerized by a man more than a quarter-mile above the streets of Manhattan, who appeared in a the sky "like a pencil mark, most of which had been erased." He did not just walk but danced on top a tightrope seven or eight times before finally handing himself over to the police. For a moment, his gesture of artistic recklessness silenced and captured the imagination of a city that does not stop moving. While his act of defiance and beauty is being performed miraculously in the metropolitan skyline, more subtle events of love, loss, and forgiveness, redemption take place below as the lives a dozen or so characters violently crash into each other or gently bump each in a brief moment of happenstance.

New York serves as the perfect setting to hold and sustain an eclectic cast of tragically beautiful characters who are as dynamic and unsettled as the city itself. McCann writes of the Big Apple, “It was a city uninterested in history. Strange things occurred precisely because there was no necessary regard for the past. The city lived in a sort of everyday present. It had no need to believe in itself as a London, or an Athens, or even a signifier of the New World, like a Sydney, or a Los Angeles. No, the city couldn't care less about where it stood." Much like the city, this characters are too busy seeking redemption and rebuilding their lives to dwell on the past; and it is through their desire to move forward and to get beyond loss that their lives overlap.

Two Irish immigrant brothers, a monk and a quiet drifter who live in the projects and minister to the downtrodden, befriend a mother-daughter prostitute team whose lives tragically intersect with a strung out bohemian married couple, who after a catastrophic event seek out a loving, well-educated black single mother who has a special relationship with a pampered but damaged Park Avenue mother who is mourning the loss of her son in Vietnam and is married to the judge who sentences both the tightrope walker and the prostitutes.

The interconnectedness between the characters isn't always obvious and sometimes blindsides the reader, but waiting for the nuanced ways that McCann interweaves the characters lives leads to the suspense and artfulness of his yarn. As one of the Irish brothers explains, "...everything in New York is built upon another thing, nothing is entirely by itself, each thing as strange as the last, and connected.”

Very much a story of six degrees of separation, the disparate stories are brought together by chance and sentiment more than complicated plot or a strong main character that drives the story and brings colorful supporting characters along for the ride. There is no main character in this novel. Each one of these characters are strong enough to have their own novel; they are individual narratives; stand-alone vignettes that are woven together in a detailed mosaic that glows and resonates. There is no "about" that unifies this book; no all encompassing theme or motif. Love, loss, fear, risk-taking, redemption, family, politics, crime, and re-invention abound equally in this novel. It is very much a book that encompasses the fleeting nature of art. Not just art in the aesthetic sense but art in the everyday articulation of life. This can be see in the way the aerialist transforms himself "....into a statue, but a perfect New York one, a temporary one, up in the air, high above the city. A statue that had no regard for the past.’’

Much like the wire walkers's ephemeral statue, I too have created a temporary expression of art inside the margins of this wonderful book that I must erase. My co-workers at the library get really pissed when I write in books. Although my scrawlings must be erased, my love for this triumph of a novel will remain as I continue to recommend this awe-inspiring work to my library patrons.

Monday, June 7, 2010

Gaming with the Great American Exaggerator

So, I did a Google search for “David Sedaris and drinking games” and no relevant hits appeared.  What a missed opportunity.  If you took a drink every time he made a self-depreciating comment about his looks, dissed his father, or cussed, you would be passed out in 47 minutes. If you added shots each time, you read the word “Greek” or “gay,” you would die of blood alcohol poisoning.   If you took a drink every time, he introduced something novel or challenging into his writing, you would be a very sober reader.

Most likely the David Sedaris drinking game won’t take off, but as parent, I probably shouldn’t be role modeling the practice of doing shots while reading anyway.  Instead, I’ll just play my new favorite David Sedaris game: Guess which essays were published in the New Yorker? (With a name that catchy, try not to be jealous that you didn’t think of it first).

I originated this game while reading “This Old House” from When You Are Engulfed in Flames. The essay originally appeared in the New Yorker on July 9, 2007 and chronicles Sedaris’ wacky stay in a boarding house in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. It is perfection from start to finish with fascinating supporting characters, great pacing, interesting plot twists, surprising revelations, humor, and tenderness. Finding all these elements in one Sedaris essay is highly unusual. Sedaris’ tales normally move rapidly from punch line to punch line with little plot development, flat characters and almost no use of traditional essay elements, which always leaves me yelling at the pages.  His blatant disrespect of the humor essay as an art form doesn’t stop his books from appearing on the New York Times Best Sellers List and Library Journal’s The Books Most Borrowed in U.S. Libraries List, nor does it stop the overwrought comparisons of him to Mark Twain. Most book critics are not essay connoisseurs, so they might not distinguish between a humorist and essayist. Twain was the rare combination of humorist and an essayist. Sedaris' works fall short of earning him the moniker of an essayist, except when his writings appear in the New Yorker.

No matter if he is called an essayist, humorist, or memoirist, people are more interested in the veracity of his stories opposed to how the editing process changes or improves the quality of his work.  In the essay, This American Lie, Alex Heard contends that Sedaris’ essays are not really truthful or all that personal. He insists that Sedaris is a fraud who creates fiction when the truth fails to be funny and exploits his family for laughs. Heard has made it his personal mission to fact check Sedaris' stories. What kind of stick do you have to have up your ass to even take on a project like that? Sedaris is not a journalist and is not obligated to follow any code of ethics other than his personal values. Sedaris has admitted repeatedly that his works are “realish” and he exaggerates for effect. Heard’s objection is not that exaggerates but that he embellishes his work too much for it to retain the label of non-fiction. 

If there is a problem with the non-fiction and fiction distinction that is an issue for the Library of Congress to resolve, or individual libraries can re-catalog his items (which completes screws up OCLC records but that is a rant for another day). Sedaris is a humorist not a librarian, so Melvin Dewey is not his problem or a problem for the critics.

The problem for critics arises when Sedaris’ reputation goes from Great American Exaggerator to Great American Essayist. If this grand distinction is ever bestowed upon him, there should be an asterisk placed by his name because having your work polished by the editors of the New Yorker is like having Bobbi Brown as your make-up artist and Rachel Zoe as your stylist, they can make anyone look good.    

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Mark Haddon Stabs Jeff Kinney in the Back with a Proverbial Garden Fork: Review of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time

Author’s Note: This post containers spoiler information about Mark Haddon’s The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time. Go ahead and take the 70 seconds to read my review, and save yourself the four to six hours that you could never get back if you waste your time on this book. Book Club Moms, here are my comments for May’s selection. I find that when I don’t like a book the meeting goes to hell quickly, so in hopes of keeping us on track, I will rant here and bring only my most positive energy to the meeting if I am able to attend. The kids’ babysitter will not return my emails or phone calls, so it isn’t looking good. Could it be because my pre-schooler tried to kill her with a jar of peanut butter? Possibly.


If I had to write a one sentence description of Mark Haddon’s The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, it would be: Rain Man meets the Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Dog Days.

Yes, that is harsh, but I will not stop there. It shocks me that this sham of a novel won the 2003 Whitbread Award and received stellar reviews. Haddon has garnered overwhelming praise for creating Christopher Boone, a fifteen-year-old boy with Asperger Syndrome (a highly functional type of autism), who is an emotionally impaired teenager who navigates through a murky world of sadness, ambivalence, anger and tragedy. The book centers on the mystery of who killed Mrs. Sheers’ dog, Wellington, with a garden fork. The deeper that the dispassionate, reasonable boy delves into the mystery the more duplicity he uncovers. The tension between the literal-minded teenager who is incapable of lying and the world of deception and misconception created by the adults around him is fascinating for about two and half chapters until the gimmicky charts and drawings start appearing to show how Christopher’s mind processes.

Every time Haddon wants to pad the plot he shows Christopher working on some long equation or making lists that have no relevance to the story but only serves to elucidate Christopher as different. It’s not character development. It is filler just like when I loaded my critical theory essays in graduate school with a bunch of Derrida and Foucault quotes. I was not trying to make an argument; I was just trying to meet the page requirements. Same thing with Haddon.

Shame on Haddon, who is not autistic, for using Asperger’s as a narrative device. Shame on most critics for not seeing this novel for the gimmick that it is. Perhaps, it is politically incorrect to criticize a book about a disability, which is precisely why I do not read books about cancer or sexual abuse either. The subject matter is too tragic for readers and critics to see objectively (through their tear-filled eyes) the other components that make a narrative strong or weak. Most readers can’t get over their own guilt about their personal happiness long enough to see these types of novels as sympathy-inducing contrivances. (Feel free to put Jodi Picoult’s My Sister’s Keeper, Elizabeth Scott’s Living Dead Girl, and A Walk to Remember by Nicholas Sparks into this category).

In theory, Haddon’s book would be sympathy-inducing if it was not so grating on the nerves. If you removed all of Christopher’s commentary about not wanting to be touched, his breakdowns when his routine is interrupted, and his extensive rambling about math, this 226 page novel would become an 80 page novella or just a really long short story about a murdered dog and a divorce. Without the Asperger’s angle, Haddon’s book becomes another divorce novel among a competitive array of divorce dramas available for adults and teens. If you are looking for a divorce novel, try out Judy Blume’s It's Not the End of the World or Diane Johnson’s Le Divorce (the book, not the dreadful movie adaptation). If you are desperate for an autism novel, try Marcelo in the Real World by Francisco X. Stork, which has been highly recommended by two trusted librarians. Supposedly, the character development is more substantial, and it is an all-around superior book.

And, aren’t we all just looking for superior books (well, those of us who are not Stephenie Meyer fans)? When it comes down to it, life is too short to read bad books, so expand your literary life by skipping this book. Or, if you already read it for book club, go bitch about for 20 minutes and then move onto more interesting topics.

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Excessive Thoughts on T.C. Boyle's Tortilla Curtain

Author’s Note: This post contains spoiler information about T.C. Boyle’s Tortilla Curtain. If you do not wish to know the ending, do not read this entry. I also caution you to stay away from the amateur book review hour at Amazon, loaded with spoilers. If you are a high school student or undergraduate looking for a summary to help you with your quiz or paper, get off the computer and go read the book. If you are in book club that I moderate, here is what I promised. Have a great meeting without me, and I apologize I will not be there to instigate tangential conversations on husbands, sex, thumb-sucking, potty training, sex, television shows, other books, ex-boyfriends, mother-in-laws and Prince. (If you are in a different book club, feel free to use any of my statements, but do not judge us for our tangents. The laughter thwarts our crying and minimizes our wine drinking).

When I closed the book cover of T.C. Boyle’s Tortilla Curtain for the last time, I felt like I do when I eat an entire bag of Dove chocolates for breakfast --- satiated, enriched, and nourished. Wonderful sensations overwhelmed me after reading this great book that challenged me, moved me, made me feel deeply for the characters, and prompted me to admire the author’s application of satire and social realism. But just like when I eat an entire bag of candy, the euphoria passed and the stomachache started….triggered this time by abyssal reviews, not sugar shock.

Time Magazine writes “This is weak, obvious stuff, worth a raised eyebrow and a shrug.” The review in New Statesman & Society states: “Boyle explores powerful issues through his parallel characters, but they operate just shy of caricature. They are more symbolic figures than real inhabitants of a state wallowing in economic downturn. The Mexicans are naive, but essentially good, while their Anglo counterparts grow increasingly ugly with rage.” And if those reviews weren’t harsh enough, World Literature Today wrote: “Perhaps if he had taken a harder-edged look, in the manner of Steinbeck, instead of the sometimes facetious one we find here, the results would have been more deeply affecting.”

The critics are right, and I have been duped into loving this book, being moved by this book, feeling deeply for these characters that might be nothing more than caricatures. It is true that Boyle’s message is simple: Mexicans are hard working and just want a shot at the American dream, and suburban whites are unemphatic, uncompassionate, and inconvenienced by illegal immigrants until they need some manual labor done for less than U.S. minimum wage.

Even though I grew up in a nearly all-white community (except for the one adopted black boy and the two adopted Vietnamese kids) and I currently live in a well-educated, affluent city with a miniscule Mexican population, I know that immigration is more complicated of an issue than the good and innocent Mexicans versus the empirical, greedy whites. So, why did I fall for this novel? Perhaps the characters are not as “flat” as the critics claim them to be. I would argue that three out of the four characters are somewhat plump if not fully round characters that are simply trapped in novel with a basic plot, a simple polemic, and puerile symbolism.

So, what do I mean by flat and round characters? These terms come from E.M. Forester’s Aspects of the Novel, and the definitions are simple. Flat characters are straight forward. They are what they are, and do not experience any changes throughout the book. These are typically characters that symbolize some type of idea like good or evil. Round characters are fully developed, thoroughly complex emotionally and socially, and undergo some type of conflict, change, and development for better or for worse. The most famous creator of flat characters is Charles Dickens. (FYI: Never call Charles Dickens’ characters flat while studying Victorian literature in England even if you have absolutely nothing else to say because you were out clubbing instead of reading Oliver Twist. The British are in denial, and they really don’t need more to put them in a dour mood. The bad weather and the bad food are plenty).

So, why is Boyle lambasted for having flat characters and not afforded the same praise as Dickens as a socio-political novelist? And, how flat are the characters? Let’s quickly review the characters:

  • Kyra Mossbacher is the flattest, most evil and least interesting character out of the four main characters. She is basically a dog-loving Cruella de Vil who has no compassion for immigrants and wants to wall out anyone who is different from her. She is an uninteresting caricature who slows the book down every time she shows a multi-million dollar house or complains about the illegals at the labor exchange, who are causing property values to drop. Does she have any redeemable qualities?
  • Delaney Mossbacher is easily the character with the most potential for change and has the power to influence the most lives in the Topanga Canyon. As a perceptive nature writer, he holds dearly onto progressive liberal views about man and nature living harmoniously, but struggles with his views on immigration. He knows that the hysteria about illegals is racist; he knows our country is a land of immigrants. But at the same time, he is barely ruffled when he nearly kills a man with his car and throws $20 at him to make him go away once he realizes he is an illegal immigrant who won’t press charges or sue. He is far more devastated that a coyote jumped over his six foot fence and killed his two dogs. What are Delaney’s redeeming qualities? If Delaney would have been more complex and would have not sheepishly joined the xenophobic frenzy, would have the outcome been different? What other options did he have? We live in a community that is indisputably green and full of environmentalists and naturalists but is nowhere near the border; do you feel any of Delaney’s sentiments in our community? I don’t know much about immigration viewpoints in our community; I just know that I fear being mulled to death by wildlife far more than immigrants. (Not for comic effect, truly my most irrational fear).
  • Cándido Rincon is less flat than Kyra, but he is essentially a caricature with an impeccable work ethic, fiery temperament and tragic childhood. Cándido becomes a symbol that Boyle uses to represent the entire Mexican culture, particularly Mexican males. He gives Candido a great sense of pride, determination, and anger; he is both protective and sexist. He is religious and traditional, particularly towards women working and his first-born child being a son. Boyle takes no risks with Cándido. He might as well be made out of cardboard. What are his redeeming qualities, and what steps could have Cándido taken to make the tragic outcome different?
  • América Rincon is the most tragic character in the novel, and her story keeps the novel moving. As a pregnant seventeen-year-old from a small Mexican village, she starts out innocently looking for the American dream complete with a T.V., a tree in the yard and a place to raise chickens. Until crossing the border with the father of her unborn baby and the former husband of her oldest sister, she led a sheltered life in safety of her father’s protection. She left her father’s protection to give her baby what the United States of America could offer. In pursuit of the American dream, she experiences great personal triumph by earning her own money. Readers feel her hope and pride right alongside her. We want to see this potential heroine succeed, but instead her money is stolen and she is raped, leaving her with a sexually transmitted disease, unable to seek medical attention or contact her mother and sisters for help. Her dream only continues to unravel more as the labor exchange is closed, thugs rob Cándido of his money; she is forced to eat garbage in the city; and, live in the wilderness of the canyon like an animal; her mental condition deteriorates to a near catatonic state; and, she gives birth to a blind baby (caused by her gonorrhoea) who drowns in a mudslide. Wow, that is a lot of contrived devastation to pull at the heartstrings, but her story is gripping, heart-wrenching and thought-provoking from cover to cover.

Boyle uses characters that range from completely flat to symbolically round to make his political points. What other techniques does he use to elucidate the story? Symbolism, multiple points of views told in alternating chapters, and third person omniscient narrator.

  • Symbolism: Boyle’s use of the coyotes to symbolize the immigrants and the community wall to represent border control is so blatantly obvious that it is unchallenging to the readers and somewhat insulting. Are there any other symbols that are not as obvious? What about the cat, the baby, the materials from the doghouse?
  • Third person omniscient narrator is used by Boyle to convey a sense of neutrality, but all of the narrator’s smug foreshadowing titbits are just annoying and distracting. Did you notice the narrator’s foreshadowing? Did you think the narrator was completely neutral in the storytelling?
  • Multiple points of views in alternating chapters: By no means is Boyle as gifted as Barbara Kingsolver in the Poisonwood Bible, but he definitely could teach Julia Alvarez a thing or two. In Saving the World, the alternating between Isabel and Alma’s stories did nothing to move the novel forward and were marginally linked. In contrast, Boyle’s use of alternating chapters about Cándido/ América and Kyra/Delaney keep the entire book together and conceal how simple the story really was. At the conclusion of each chapter, Boyle is able leave the readers in a state of suspense. Readers rapidly get through the next chapter to get back to the other story. He sprinkles the characters marginally into each other stories in order to keep the reader interested and not willing to skip one half of the novel (which is possible in both Larson’s Devil in the White City and Alvarez’s Saving the World, but probably better just to skip her whole novel .)

It is a truly skillful author that can use structure and form to make a simplistic idea and rudimentary symbolism seem like great literature. It is unfortunate that when Boyle broke the narrative structure and put the characters together in the final chapter, the entire novel collapsed. The ending reads like Boyle got bored with his characters, and just wanted to call it a wrap. So, he created a bunch of drama with the gun, the mudslide, and the river in order to the kill the baby (who symbolizes the American dream) and so that the brown man save the white man.

The conclusion is so heavy handed that the simplistic message probably eradicates any complexity that did exist in the book. Perhaps with a different ending, this book would not have been so widely panned by literary critics. So although I agree with critics that this novel is not literary fiction, I still love this book because it made me think; it made me feel; it made me focus on literary style and structure. I give it a big thumbs up and would recommend it to my patrons.

So, there you have it, 1,914 words that I wrote for you just for fun. Oh, it just would have been easier to have found a babysitter.

Monday, April 26, 2010

Why I Won’t Read or Recommend David Pelzer

As an avid reader of essays and literary non-fiction, I never heard of David Pelzer. He simply wasn’t good enough to pop up on my radar of writers worth reading. Then, I became a public librarian, and at least once a week, someone would ask me for “A Child Called It.”

So I had to find out, why was Pelzer appealing to reluctant readers who normally just came into the library for DVDs, to glance at the Want Ads, and to use our computers? Pelzer’s allure is quite simple: he writes horror stories about child abuse with gruesome details in an easy to read style filled with colloquialisms and clichés, making his writings unintentional high-low books (high interest level/low reading level, which means content geared towards teens and adults at a basic reading level).

For every reason his books attract reluctant readers, there is a reason for library professionals not to recommend his books (although we should always give his books to our patrons if they ask for them by name and do not request our opinion): the gratuitous violence that has been reported by Pelzer’s family members to be absolutely false, Pelzer’s stature as a professional victim, the substantiated claim that he keeps himself on the New York Times Best Sellers List for Paperbacks by purchasing large quantities of his books at a discounted price and reselling them at his sold-out talks across the country. Although Pelzer’s behavior is despicable and unveracious, these reasons are not enough for me to suppress his books from my reader’s advisory service.

But, the fact that he calls himself “the Robin Williams of Child Abuse” is simply reprehensible.