Saturday, February 14, 2009

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

The Poetry of Life and Death on February 11

In her iconic poem Lady Lazarus, Sylvia Plath writes:

Dying
Is an art, like everything else,
I do it exceptionally well.

I do it so it feels like hell.
I do it so it feels real.
I guess you could say I've a call.

She succeeded in her calling on February 11, 1963 – her second suicide attempt. She was 30.

My first child was born February 11, 1999. I was 25.

Now every February 11 as I celebrate the anniversary of my son’s birth; I take moment to think about Plath, an amazingly talented but deeply-troubled writer, probably known more for her tumultuous personal life and mental health struggles than her poetry, written in the confessional style. This just means she wrote diary entries in stanzas with rhyme, meter and a Smith College educated vocabulary.

On the anniversary of her death, I also wonder about the children who she left behind. The children who miraculously did not die on the day their mother ended her life. Plath carefully sealed the rooms between herself and her sleeping children before she took her life by turning on her gas oven. Frieda was 2 and Nicholas was 1.

Many interesting facts exist about Plath and appear repeatedly in publications: Married to English poet Ted Hughes; posthumously awarded a Pulitzer for her Collected Poems; completed a guest editorship at Mademoiselle; first tried to commit suicide at the age of 20; father died when she was 8; and, she experienced a difficult relationship with her mother. Typically, the children are nothing more than a footnote for the hundreds of publishers, scholars, and biographers who have profited and made careers by capitalizing on Plath’s struggle with mental illness, her disastrous marriage to Hughes, and her tragic death,

With so much drama, the innocent are easily forgotten. I was guilty of the oversight too. During my 20s, when I didn’t make much distinction between leaving behind 2 children and leaving behind 2 books of unpublished poetry, I would have believed that not being around to receive a Pulitzer was a far greater tragedy than not seeing some kids reach adulthood. In those days, I consumed Plath’s poetry, the way Lady Lazarus consumed men, like air. I was a self-indulgent college student who hated my mother for no good reason; wrote horribly bad self-absorbed poetry; and, amused myself by scaring friends and family with vague insinuations about suicide. Whining, not dying, was my art.

Being a good Catholic girl, I feared a vengeful and wrathful God who takes self-murder pretty seriously. And even more terrifying than the threat of an eternity in hell was the possibility of not succeeding and dealing with my vengeful and wrathful mother. My mother was much like Aurelia Plath but meaner. I imagined that she would hand me knife and say: “Do it until you do it right.” Or, she would lock my crazy ass up indefinitely and tell people that her loving, selfless daughter became a missionary in Afghanistan—never to be heard from again. With those thoughts to guide me, I stayed far away far from sleeping pills and gas ovens. I made it into adulthood safely and eventually became both less whiny and a mother of four children.

Now when I read Ariel, I am still amazed by the urgency, the beauty of language and unrelenting tragic desperation in each verse, but that is where my celebration of her poetry now ends. Ariel immortalizes for Frieda and Nicholas their mother’s history of depression, anger, hopelessness, tragedy, and suicidal obsessions.

In her forward of Ariel Restored, Frieda Hughes writes about her mother: "She used every emotional experience as if it were a scrap of material that could be pieced together to make a wonderful dress." For her children, Plath’s wonderful dress is more like corset that is fascinating and strangely beautiful on the exterior but brings excruciating pain to the core.

In a 2007 interview with Time, Andrea Sachs asks: If all of this had happened to your mom now, what people know now, do you think it would have resulted in her death? With modern pharmacology, could somebody have helped her?

Frieda replied: “I think there's no doubt about that. The advancements in the past 30- or 40-odd years are huge. I don't believe there's any way that that situation would have arisen now. She'd still be here.”

If Plath would have gotten the medical attention that she needed, chances are the literary world would have been denied one the best poetry collections of the Twentieth Century. And without her illness, there probably wouldn’t been much art from Plath and most likely no great art. Sylvia Plath would have been another 1960s mother on mood-altering drugs. Frieda and Nicholas Hughes would have just been kids with a mom, who was living with a little help from antidepressants.

Saturday, January 10, 2009

Review: Sloane Crosley's I Was Told There'd Be Cake

Simply put, I was too chicken to move to New York and pursue a career in writing. So when I heard about Sloane Crosley’s debut essay collection I was Told There'd Be Cake, I was eager to get a glimpse of the life that I skipped.

Read it cover to cover, and I am still not sure what I missed by heading to Texas instead of New York. The picture given in these essays are so close-up, so personal, and so self-focused that Crosley misses the opportunity to show the New York writing scene in a new light. And instead she chronicles the all too familiar tale of a twenty-something New Yorker who grew up in the suburbs and moved to the city to work in publishing. Like every other young, attractive, intelligent, single professional alone in New York, she experiences mean bosses, bad neighbors, and an unpleasant moving experience – breaking no new ground in terms of theme or content. But Crosley does offer some moments that that are witty and wry such as “…bringing him back to my bed made me feel like a prostitute whereas going to his place made me feel like a call girl.” She constructs strong sentences with vivid language and clever similes “Do unto others…was a concept that had slid off me like water off an oil-slicked baby seal’s back.”

Eloquent language and interesting syntax, however, cannot save this collection from shallowness and singularity; her lack of universally relatable stories turns her collection of essays into a compilation of a well-crafted diary entries. She fills the book with pop-culture references that are lost anyone even slightly over the age of 35 and that certainly will not stand the test of time. When she is not referencing 1990s computer games and movies, Crosley embraces self-absorption and self-indulgence. She reflects and contemplates too much, and it is not the type of reflection that is for the greater good of humanity, although she would like to think so. She writes: “…I can say with a solid degree of authority that I am a selfish person. I spontaneously forget the names of more people than not, unless I want to make out with them. I will take the last square of toilet paper off the roll without thinking twice. I tip taxi drivers so poorly I'm amazed none of them have run over my foot while speeding off. Once I became so annoyed at a boyfriend's excessive use of my overpriced shea butter-based shampoo that I went out and bought him some Prell.”

She repeatedly babbles about mall life (“...mall as ecosphere” and “…our bubble-like mall existence would have to come to end…”), in hopes that she offers some higher metaphorical meanings. She doesn’t. Her essays reek of a sheltered young adulthood without enough distance from it to glean any meaningful message from her privileged suburban sanctuary although she tries repeatedly to understand, justify and exploit her white-picket-fence upbringing, particularly in “Bastard out of Westchester.”

Crosley reveals a blurred focal point in "Bastard out of Westchester." It is not the intentional post-modern kind but instead the “I don’t have a thesis statement” kind. The essay begins with the strange pronouncement that she wants to have a child born in Oostende or Antwerp. She explains: “This is where I want to raise my children—until the age, of say, ten, when I’ll cruelly rip them out of the stream where they’re fly-fishing with their other lederhosened friends and move to them to place like Lansdale, Pennsylvania.” She splits this topic into a tangent about her one year of childhood in Australia followed by a somewhat complimentary digression about life in the suburbs. Her reflective paragraphs on the suburbs are the most poignant in the essay and are some of the best in the entire collection. She writes: “Suburbia is too close to the country to have anything real to do and too close to the city to admit you have nothing real to do. Its purpose is to make it so you can identify with everything. We obviously grew up indentifying with nothing,” and concludes “…I came to understand that being born and raised in suburbia makes it difficult to lay claim to a specific type of childhood.” But unwillingly to let the essay end with that mature, honest, and introspective note that minimizes the incoherent logic at the beginning of the essay, she starts rambling about her name. This portion of the essay could have been written as a separate essay, put on her blog, or emailed to a friend. (Perhaps reflection on one’s name is just a natural act for twenty-somethings. When I was 21, I wrote an essay titled, “Call me Cornucopia,” which focused on my painfully common first and last names, how I was named after a soap character in the 70s, and how frustrating it was to attend college with someone who had the same name. I wanted a unique name like Cornucopia, but Sloane probably would have worked well too. Why is she complaining?) The disconnected subject matter that begins and ends the essay gives the entire piece a disjointed and forced perspective.

Perhaps "Bastard out of Westchester" suffers from Crosley’s use of compression. In her author’s note, she cops to using compression to bring pieces of stories together in a contained manner. Traditionally, compression may mean collapsing a week’s worth of events into a day or writing about three supporting characters instead of the seven who were there. Crosley, however, uses the type of compression performed by desperate college students who want to use the same paper for 2 classes. Like the kid who combines his history and political science papers into one mammoth catchall to satisfy two professors (or in my case, contrives a horrible comparison between As You like It and Crime and Punishment because I was taking Shakespeare and Russian literature in the same semester), Crosley throws together a bunch incomplete pieces to create a larger incomplete piece.

Like her essay about the suburbs, foreign-born children, and her unique name, "Ursula’s Cookie" also suffers from compression and feels like four separate essays. The first part reads like a Devil Wears Prada rip-off that focuses on her first grown-up job working assistant for a mean publisher boss. The second part, which reads like a scene out of absurdist theatre, shows her creating a cookie in the shape of her boss’s head; the third part focuses on a ridiculous lie about a family member’s death that leads to her eventual resignation; and, the fourth part shows her awkward resignation on September 11, 2001. The entire essay could have been framed about the insignificance of her unpleasant boss and trivial job in relation to the collapse of her surroundings, but instead her banal resignation on a tragically historic day makes for a quick and dreadfully quirky ending to an interminable piece about a drug dealing boyfriend, misshaped cookies, a dead aunt, and a living father. Perhaps the understatement is intentional, but most likely; the ending is swift because somber isn’t as cool as pithy and acerbic.

Crosely can be funny, caustic, and definitely self-deprecating. She makes herself the star of her show, but creates herself more as an uneven caricature than a well-rounded character. She portrays herself as a mean girl but tempers it with contrived, unbelievable benevolence (more to appeal to readers than to accurately reflect her true self). She makes herself the butt of her jokes, which ignites laughter but not empathy. Slapstick moments, gross-out jokes, and scathing comedic wisecracks summon snickers and sometimes genuine belly laughs, but rarely produce reader compassion. Likewise, she doesn’t give us any interesting supporting characters just a few funny quotes from her mother and sketchy portrayals of loser boyfriends and exasperating high school friends. She never moves the lens enough far away from herself to develop New York as a character or even as scenery. But at the same time, the lens is so close that it obscures her image. Readers of her 15 essays don’t really learn much about Sloane Crosley. In this collection, she is never a reliable, steadfast narrator but instead appears as the slightly drunk cute girl at a cocktail party who tells funny, embarrassing stories to pick up guys.

Sadly, Crosley achieves with her collection of essays the noncommittal, fly-by-night relationship that she desperately seeks in her essay, "One Night Bounce." In this essay, she expresses an obsession with one-night stands. Although, according to her comical account, she never succeeds in real life, she accomplishes this feat with her readers. She gives us a quick jolly with her funny quips about weddings in “You on a Stick”; violates us a little with “Smell This,” a somewhat gross tale about a mysterious piece excrement on her bathroom floor; and, makes us feel a bit of uncomfortable with revelations about her plastic toy collection in “The Pony Problem.” It was fun while it lasted but it doesn’t make us want to see her again unless maybe we’re bored and have nothing do the next time she puts out...a collection of essays.